The review was written while the game was still in development.
Considering the second part of the series, I'm scared to imagine what Rockstar will roll out. The breakthrough success and cult status that the second part acquired is a very, very high bar that the third part must pass. Rockstar has always made good games and, based on the GTA series, they have never made projects worse than they were.
Now talking about what is worth and what should not be expected in the new RDR is stupidity, there is no information, only rumors, but there is a flight of fancy)
In any case, I will wait for this project, because, as it seems to me, this will be something with something, again a breakthrough and an example for all games