The review was written while the game was still in development.
Perhaps the announcement of the fourth Witcher was the most unexpected and pleasant announcement of the past 22nd year. But it will be a completely different story without Geralt and other characters familiar to us. And the guild will be different and perhaps there will be little left of the Witcher there. So far, we haven’t been shown any gameplay or even screenshots, so it’s hard to say what awaits us in the new Witcher