The review was written while the game was still in development.
Oh, those “not like everyone else” who will criticize every low-poly stone on release just because of the popularity of the series.
Well, in general, not a single previous project of Rockstars disappointed at all. RDR and GTA had very interesting and well-thought-out worlds, and in the trailer they seemed to be combined.
Based on the same leaks, it is clear that many mechanics will be taken from RDR, which is rather good, because the game is excellent, but I hope they will be made more in-depth. I don’t see any point in saying anything about the “GTA part”, the series has been pleasing for decades, and I hope Rockstars will not disappoint and GTA 6 will not be the finale.