The review was written while the game was still in development.
The first two parts made a pleasant impression on me in terms of plot, mechanics, physics and more. But they screwed up the 3rd part and even the return of old characters from Mafia 2 did not improve the situation. I hope that in part 4 they will show us what happened between the events of parts 2 and 3; it would also be nice if the developers showed what happened before the plot of parts 1 or 2. In any case, I'll be looking forward to this game.