Mysticism / Supernatural for PlayStation 5 — top best games in the Mysticism / Supernatural genre

Silent Hill f - a game in the Mysticism / Supernatural genre

Action, Adventure, Horror, Third-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 25 September 2025

VGTimes: 8.4/10

Players: 7.8/10

Metacritic: 84/100

A full-fledged sequel to the cult horror series Silent Hill. The action takes place in the 1960s in the Japanese town of Ebisugaoka. The story tells of a schoolgirl...

Alan Wake 2

Action, Adventure, Horror, Third-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Shooter

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 27 October 2023

Players: 8.5/10

Metacritic: 89/100

Saga Anderson, an experienced FBI agent, is sent to the city of Bright Falls on the Pacific Northwest coast. In this town, hidden among mountains and forests, a...

Nioh 2: Complete Edition

Role-playing game, Fantasy / Medieval, Third-person view, Action, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 5 February 2021

Players: 8.5/10

Metacritic: 86/100

Nioh 2: Complete Edition — the complete edition of the hardcore role-playing action game Nioh 2 with a third-person view in Japanese style, including all...

The Callisto Protocol

Action, Futurism (Future), Third-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Stealth, Survival horror, Science fiction, Adventure, Horror

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 2 December 2022

Players: 7.7/10

Metacritic: 69/100

Fantastic horror The Callisto Protocol is created in the mold of Dead Space: the cramped quarters of a distant space station are filled with biophage...

Ghostwire: Tokyo

Action, Adventure, Futurism (Future), First-person view, Shooter, Mysticism / Supernatural, Open world, Exploration

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 22 March 2022

Players: 8.6/10

Metacritic: 78/100

The game takes place in modern Tokyo. The plot begins at the famous Shibuya pedestrian crossing, when in an instant absolutely all the inhabitants of the city...

Hell is Us

Action, Adventure, Third-person view, Futurism (Future), Post-apocalyptic, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 4 September 2025

Players: 7.6/10

Metacritic: 78/100

Adventure action in a science-fiction setting from the creators of Necromunda: Underhive Wars. The main character finds himself in an isolated country where...

Weird West

Role-playing game, Isometric, Adventure, Action, Tactics, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 8 May 2023

Players: 7.3/10

Metacritic: 77/100

The game takes place in the world of the unusual and gloomy Wild West, where sheriffs and bandits exist along with fantastic creatures. Players find themselves in a...

Alone in the Dark

Action, Horror, Third-person view, Adventure, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 20 March 2024

Players: 8.9/10

Metacritic: 65/100

Explore a world full of mysteries and dangers in Alone in the Dark— an adventure game with elements of horror and survival set in a noir atmosphere and...

Content Warning

Action, Online, First-person view, Cooperative (co-op), Mysticism / Supernatural, Exploration, Procedural generation, Survival horror

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 1 April 2026

Players: 8.2/10

A cooperative horror puzzle game in the spirit of Lethal Company. The game is about a group of bloggers trying to get viral on the local equivalent of YouTube. To...

Life is Strange: Double Exposure

Adventure, Interactive movie, Mysticism / Supernatural, Action, Third-person view

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 29 October 2024

Players: 8.3/10

Metacritic: 74/100

The main character is Max Caulfield from the first part of Life is Strange. This time, the girl is investigating the cause of her friend's death. To do this, Max...

Inscryption

Card game, Horror, Roguelike, First-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Puzzle

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 30 August 2022

Players: 9.6/10

Metacritic: 86/100

Inscryption is a first-person card puzzle horror game from the creator of Pony Island. In the game, you will find yourself in the cabin of Leshy, from which you...

Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden

Action, Adventure, Role-playing game, Mysticism / Supernatural, Third-person view

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 13 February 2024

Players: 8.2/10

Metacritic: 79/100

New Eden, 1695. The main characters are ghost hunters Anthea Duarte and Red Mac Wright. During one of the quests, Anthea dies and becomes one of the spirits. The...

Alan Wake Remastered

Adventure, Action, Mysticism / Supernatural, Horror, Third-person view

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 5 October 2021

Players: 8.3/10

Metacritic: 80/100

Alan Wake Remastered — a remaster of the atmospheric third-person action-adventure game. The game features updated graphics and all expansions, as well as developer...

Choo-Choo Charles

Adventure, Shooter, Horror, First-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Indie

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 21 December 2023

Players: 6.9/10

Metacritic: 56/100

Choo-Choo Charles is a psychological horror shooter with a first-person view in an open world, in which you have to run away from a monster engine that resembles a...

BloodRayne: Terminal Cut

Action, Slasher, Adventure, Third-person view, Horror, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 18 November 2021

Players: 10/10

BloodRayne: Terminal Cut — updated version of the action-adventure slasher Bloodrayne. The original game has received support for modern gamepads and optimization...

Blacktail

Action, Shooter, First-person view, Adventure, Mysticism / Supernatural, Fantasy / Medieval, Role-playing game

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 15 December 2022

Players: 8.9/10

Metacritic: 80/100

Blacktail is an adventure action-shooter with RPG elements and a first-person view in a fantasy setting from the creators of Layers of Fear, Observer , and...

Afterdream

Adventure, Horror, Walking Simulator, Side view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Puzzle

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 28 September 2023

The events of the game unfold around a girl who is lost in a lucid dream, where the line between reality and imagination has blurred. The heroine finds herself in a...

Ghostbusters: Spirits Unleashed

Action, Shooter, Online, First-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Cooperative (co-op)

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 18 October 2022

Metacritic: 70/100

A game based on the cult franchise "Ghostbusters" from the creators of Predator: Hunting Grounds and Friday the 13th: The Game. The game is an asymmetrical...

Life is Strange: Reunion

Action, Adventure, Third-person view, Interactive movie, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 26 March 2026

Players: 10/10

Metacritic: 75/100

The game continues the story of Max Caulfield and Chloe Price from Life is Strange and Life is Strange: Double Exposure. Max still struggles to accept the loss of...

Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss

Adventure, Horror, First-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 16 April 2026

Players: 1/10

Metacritic: 67/100

Psychological horror, inspired by Howard Phillips Lovecraft. The main character is Noah, an agent of the secret department of Interpol Ancile, specializing in the...

Hard West 2

Strategy, Isometric, Turn-based, Tactics, Mysticism / Supernatural, Demons

Game in development: PlayStation 5 → 2026

Players: 7.8/10

Metacritic: 77/100

Hard West 2 is a continuation of the exciting turn-based tactical western with an isometric camera view. The game takes place in the Wild West. The main character...

Gylt

Adventure, Horror, Third-person view, Puzzle, Indie, Action, Exploration, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 6 July 2023

Players: 8.4/10

Metacritic: 70/100

The main character is a little girl, Sally, who one day, fleeing from a group of bullies, finds herself in a distorted version of her city, where her fears and...

Werewolf: The Apocalypse - Earthblood

Role-playing game, Horror, Third-person view, Fantasy / Medieval, Action, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 4 February 2021

Players: 7.7/10

Metacritic: 53/100

Werewolf: The Apocalypse — Earthblood is a dark and cruel game based on the cult universe of everyone's favorite Vampire: The Masquerade — Bloodlines...

The Occultist

Action, Adventure, First-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Detective, Survival horror

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 8 April 2026

VGTimes: 6.8/10

Players: 10/10

Metacritic: 68/100

Psychological horror, where players will take on the role of a paranormal investigator and venture to the strange island of Godstone. The plot of the game revolves...

Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly Remake

Action, Adventure, Third-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Remake, Survival horror

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 12 March 2026

Metacritic: 76/100

A remake of the classic psychological horror game Fatal Frame 2: Crimson Butterfly, the story of two twin sisters is brought to life in terrifying detail. Mio and...

Crisol: Theater of Idols

Action, Shooter, Adventure, Horror, First-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 10 February 2026

Players: 8/10

Metacritic: 74/100

The game takes place in the sinister world of Hispania, a nightmarish interpretation of Spain. The protagonist is Gabriel, a soldier with an unusual gift to turn...

Tesla Force

Action, Shooter, Indie, Top-down view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Role-playing game

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 24 November 2020

Players: 8/10

Metacritic: 67/100

Tesla Force is a dynamic shooter with role-playing elements and a top-down view. In the game you have to choose one of four geniuses initiated into secret...

Atlas Fallen: Reign Of Sand

Action, Adventure, Role-playing game, Exploration, Fantasy, Demons, Cooperative (co-op), Mysticism / Supernatural, Third-person view

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 10 August 2023

Players: 7/10

The game takes place in a world inhabited by ancient monsters that the main characters have to hunt. They set off on a journey through the sands of the eternal land...

Sherlock Holmes The Awakened

Detective, Adventure, Third-person view, Puzzle, Action, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 11 April 2023

Players: 8.3/10

Metacritic: 73/100

Remake of the 2007 adventure of the same name, in which the famous London detective confronts a mysterious cult worshiping Cthulhu. A young Sherlock investigates a...

Nightmare Reaper

Shooter, First-person view, Roguelike, Old school, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 18 May 2023

Players: 3.2/10

Metacritic: 73/100

An old-school bloody shooter featuring a brutal mix of modern and classic 2.5D shooters. The game has open levels with crowds of enemies, secrets and treasures, 80...

Slender: The Arrival

Adventure, Horror, First-person view, Indie, Walking Simulator, Exploration, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 18 October 2023

Players: 8/10

Metacritic: 63/100

Continuation of the atmospheric horror with a first-person view Slender. The story tells of Slenderman, a paranormal figure who haunts inquiring minds around the...

BloodRayne 2: Terminal Cut

Adventure, Action, Slasher, Third-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Horror

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 18 February 2022

Players: 7.3/10

BloodRayne 2: Terminal Cut is an updated version of the action-adventure slasher BloodRayne 2. The original game has received support for modern gamepads and...

Bye Sweet Carole

Adventure, Horror, Platformer, Side view, Mysticism / Supernatural, Fantasy

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 9 October 2025

Players: 10/10

Metacritic: 72/100

A dark and captivating fairy tale that pays stunning homage to 1930s animation. Set in early 20th-century England against the backdrop of the burgeoning women's...

Haunted House

Action, Roguelike, Isometric, Adventure, Mysticism / Supernatural, Survival horror

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 12 October 2023

Metacritic: 70/100

Reimagining the original Haunted House (1981), released in 1981 and considered one of the first survival horror games. The main character is the niece of a...

Ad Infinitum

Action, First-person view, Horror, Historical, Mysticism / Supernatural, Stealth

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 14 September 2023

Players: 7.6/10

Metacritic: 69/100

The main character is a German soldier from the First World War who is haunted by nightmares. Although it ended, the horrors of those events still remained with the...

Slitterhead

Adventure, Horror, Action, Third-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 8 November 2024

Metacritic: 65/100

Adventure horror based on Japanese urban legends from the author of the original Silent Hill. The game takes place on the densely built-up streets of Koulong...

Control Resonant

Action, Shooter, Adventure, Third-person view, Futurism (Future), Mysticism / Supernatural

Game in development: PlayStation 5 → 2026

Anticipation Rating: 9.5/10

The main character, Dylan Faden, who spent many years in isolation within the Federal Bureau of Control, finds himself at the center of a new supernatural crisis...

Post Trauma

Adventure, Action, Horror, Third-person view, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 22 April 2025

Players: 8/10

Metacritic: 66/100

Surreal horror in the spirit of the first parts of Silent Hill. The plot of the game tells about a simple train conductor who finds himself in an otherworldly and...

The Bridge Curse 2: The Extrication

Adventure, Horror, First-person view, Walking Simulator, Exploration, Mysticism / Supernatural

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 24 October 2024

Players: 8/10

A direct sequel to the original The Bridge Curse Road to Salvation. The game has many secrets and riddles that the player solves as the story progresses. The game...

The Mortuary Assistant

Horror, Mysticism / Supernatural, Demons, Adventure, Indie, Exploration, First-person view

Game released: PlayStation 5 → 2 August 2024

Players: 7.1/10

Metacritic: 73/100

The game takes place in a morgue, where the character is urgently called to work one night. However, the hero could not even imagine what was waiting for him there...

Mysticism / Supernatural

Best Games in the Mysticism / Supernatural genre for PlayStation 5