EU Proposes Ban on Paid Loot Boxes for Under-18s

EU Proposes Ban on Paid Loot Boxes for Under-18s

Marat Usupov
Today, 16:03
Contents
Contents

The European Commission has proposed to bar paid loot boxes and lock in-game currency for under-18s until a parent approves it. It is a draft, not yet a law.

Adults would keep loot boxes: they would see the odds and get a way to switch the boxes off. Early reports described the draft differently, and the published text, which came out on 11 November, differs from them in a few places that matter.

In short

  • The Digital Fairness Act is a draft regulation published on 11 November 2026. The European Parliament and the Council, which represents the governments of EU countries, still have to agree on it.
  • Where a game is aimed at minors, or the company knows minors play it, paid loot boxes and pay-to-win purchases (purchases needed, or presented as needed, to progress or win) would not be offered to under-18s, and in-game currency would stay locked until a parent approves it.
  • For every player, loot box odds would be shown and loot boxes could be switched off.
  • Items bought with in-game currency would show a real-money price, in the currency the player paid with.
  • Two industry groups call the draft unworkable. The Commission says it gives online shoppers the protection they already have in stores.

What the draft actually is

The Digital Fairness Act is not only about games. The Commission presented it as a general update of online consumer protection. Fake claims that a product is almost sold out, subscriptions that are hard to cancel, hidden influencer ads and hidden fees sit in the same document. Games get three of its articles in the proposal text.

It is a regulation, not a directive. A directive has to be turned into national law country by country, while a regulation applies in every EU country at once. The Commission says it would also turn the existing EU rules on unfair commercial practices into a regulation, to reduce the patchwork of national rules.

Our October explainer and our news report on the leak were written before the text was public.

Loot boxes: odds and an off switch for everyone, a ban for minors

The draft's legal term is "paid-for variable reward systems". In plain terms, these are loot boxes, prize wheels and card packs that a player gets for money or for paid in-game currency, where the reward is random or the odds vary. Free random drops are not covered.

For every player, adult or child. The game company must say what a box can contain and the odds of getting each item. It must also give players an easy way to switch these systems off. This is the "off button" from early reports, and it is not limited to children.

For minors. Where a product is aimed at minors, or the company is "aware with reasonable certainty" that minors use it, the company "shall not offer" paid loot boxes to them. That is a ban, and no parent can switch it on. The Commission's own question-and-answer page lists loot boxes among the gambling-like features the act bans for minors.

Our earlier headline, written from a leaked draft, said loot boxes would be turned off by default for minors. The published text is different: "off by default" applies to in-game currency, while paid loot boxes for minors are banned.

For adults the draft stops at odds and the off switch. The Commission's impact assessment, a long study published with the proposal, says it looked at banning paid in-game currency and pay-to-win for all consumers and dropped those options early, mainly because of their effect on business models and on players' experience.

What should the EU do about paid loot boxes?

Results

In-game currency: a real-money price and a parent's approval

This rule covers the coins, gems and crystals that players buy with real money. It makes two demands.

A real-money price. When a player pays with this currency, the company must show what the item is worth in money, or an estimate, "in the currency in which the consumer acquired the first virtual currency". The draft does not say "euros": a player who buys coins in dollars would see dollars. If the value cannot be read directly, the Commission's notes that accompany the articles allow an estimate based on what the player would pay in full, without bulk discounts or special offers. Loyalty points are not counted as in-game currency.

Say an item costs 1,200 gems while a pack holds 800 (a made-up example). Nobody sees real money at the moment of choice. The Commission's notes say that such currencies make it harder to judge the true cost of a purchase.

A parent's approval. Where a product is aimed at minors or the company knows they use it, in-game currency is "disabled by default". It can be switched on only with the approval of a parent or guardian.

There is an exception. The price rule and the loot box ban for minors do not apply to social networks, video-sharing platforms, AI companions and general chatbots. They fall under a separate proposal on children's safety online, the EU KIDS Act. The currency lock and the pay-to-win rule have no such exception.

Pay-to-win and the question of who counts as a child

The pay-to-win rule is short. Under the same conditions, companies "shall not offer" pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms to minors. These are purchases that are "necessary or are presented as necessary" for progress or success. The Commission's notes give examples: artificial difficulty barriers, "progression speeds that render the unpaid path illusory", and contests decided by spending.

Two questions decide how far the rules reach. Who is a minor? Anyone under 18. When do the rules apply? In two cases: the game is aimed at minors, or the company is aware with reasonable certainty that minors play it. The notes give an example for each. A game counts as aimed at minors if it has an age rating, from the company or from a third party such as PEGI, saying it is suitable for people under 18. A company is aware of a minor player if the game is played through an account that it can tell belongs to a minor.

This is the main point of dispute. PEGI ratings such as 7, 12 and 16 say what a game is suitable for, not whom it is aimed at. Industry groups argue that the draft would treat every game rated below PEGI 18 as a children's product and so set an 18+ bar for many game features. How this is read will be decided by the final text and, later, by courts. The rating example sits in the Commission's notes, not in the articles themselves.

Which rule applies to whom: Articles 14 to 16 of the Digital Fairness Act draft
Which rule applies to whom: Articles 14 to 16 of the Digital Fairness Act draft

What already applies today

Some of this already exists, though none of it is the Digital Fairness Act. In March 2025 the EU network of national consumer authorities published seven key principles on in-game currencies. They explain how existing consumer law applies and are not a new law. On 30 September 2026 the network opened action against nine game companies, among them Supercell, King, Mojang, Riot Games and Ubisoft. The Commission named games that need further assessment, including Candy Crush Saga, Minecraft, Valorant and Clash of Clans. These are investigations, not findings of a violation.

The Dutch consumer authority fined Epic Games about 1.1 million euros in total over Fortnite practices aimed at children, such as direct urging to buy and misleading timers in the item shop. The decision became final in January 2026. It was not a fine for loot boxes. Belgium's economy ministry said in June 2025 that paid loot boxes are banned there by the gambling commission.

Read also: Sued for Being Too Addictive: How the Makers of Fortnite, Roblox and Minecraft Ended Up in Court — a look at the lawsuits and fines game companies have already faced over addictive design, from Epic's Fortnite settlement to cases still working through the courts.

Who objects

The Commission presents the draft as giving online shoppers the protection they have in stores. Commissioner Michael McGrath called it "the most ambitious reform of EU consumer protection rules in a generation".

In the European Parliament, the Socialists and Democrats group (S&D) welcomed the draft. Its Maltese member Alex Agius Saliba said "we deeply regret that addictive design was left off the list" of banned practices. Its Spanish member Laura Ballarín Cereza said "Online, we are all vulnerable", arguing that protection should cover adults too. The liberal Renew Europe group also backed protection from manipulation but asked for simpler rules and less overlap with other laws.

Video Games Europe and the European Games Developer Federation (EGDF) answered the same day with a joint statement. They call the draft "unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate". Their main arguments:

  • Pay-to-win and pay-to-progress are not defined clearly enough. The ban "could cover almost any purchase in a game", so developers could not be sure their game complies.
  • In their reading, the draft would ban virtually all in-game purchases for players under 18 and leave parents no say. That is their interpretation: the articles cover in-game currency, paid loot boxes and pay-to-progress mechanics, not every purchase.
  • Industry self-regulation already works, they say, through PEGI ratings and parental controls on consoles, PC and mobile.

Their counter-offer: purchases and chat switched off for children until a parent turns them on, clear real-money prices and refunds for unused currency.

Who should decide whether a teenager can buy in-game currency?

Results

What the Commission's own tests found

The impact assessment includes experiments in a game simulation. They are the closest thing in the file to evidence about player behaviour, but they are experiments, not market data, and not a forecast of what the industry would lose.

In the main experiment, with participants aged 15 and older in five EU countries, around 62% chose to opt out of loot boxes when they were offered that choice.

In a separate test with children aged 12 to 17, the option to opt out of loot boxes lowered average spending by about 1.93 euros, from 7.95 to 6.02 euros. Showing real-money prices instead of only in-game prices also lowered spending. Showing the odds alone barely changed behaviour: the share buying loot boxes moved from 29.7% to 28.8%, and spending fell by only 0.43 euros, which is not statistically significant.

The odds rule applies to all players under the draft, and in the Commission's own test it did little on its own. The assessment compared four packages of measures and preferred the third: paid loot boxes and pay-to-win banned for minors, with in-game currency off by default. The draft follows that package closely.

Spending of 12 to 17-year-olds in the Commission's game simulation, in euros
Spending of 12 to 17-year-olds in the Commission's game simulation, in euros

What happens next

The proposal now goes to the European Parliament and the Council, which can change it. The final text may differ from the draft in every point above. The draft says the regulation would enter into force on the twentieth day after publication in the EU's Official Journal and would apply 12 months after that. The date is still in square brackets in the text, and the Commission has not given a calendar date.

Fines are set by each country. In coordinated cross-border cases the draft requires that fines of at least 4% of annual turnover in the countries concerned are possible, or at least 2 million euros if turnover is unknown. A separate proposal would let the Commission itself fine very large cross-border cases up to 6% of worldwide turnover. It covers breaches likely to affect consumers in at least two thirds of EU countries, with at least two thirds of the EU population, and companies that are not small or medium-sized. The 6% figure in reports belongs to that second proposal, which also needs approval.

Read also: «Stop Killing Games» — what is this movement and how it could forever change the gaming industry — another EU-level push to regulate the industry, this one aimed at publishers shutting down games players already paid for.
The path of the proposal: from the Commission to the Official Journal
The path of the proposal: from the Commission to the Official Journal

What to remember

The draft separates three things that headlines mix: a ban for minors, a switch for everyone and a price tag for in-game currency. For developers, the unsettled part is the definition: which games count as aimed at minors, and where pay-to-win begins.

Take a 12-year-old with a tablet. If the draft became law as written, and the game counts as aimed at minors or the company knows a child plays it, the paid chest would not be offered to her and the gems would wait for a parent's approval. Whether the text survives Parliament and the Council in that form is the open question.

Frequently asked questions

Is the EU banning loot boxes?

Not yet, and not for everyone. It is a proposal. As drafted, paid loot boxes would not be offered to minors, while adults would get odds and an off switch.

Is the Digital Fairness Act law, and when could it apply?

It is not law. Parliament and the Council must first agree on a text. The draft would apply 12 months after entering into force, and no calendar date exists yet.

Will in-game prices be shown in euros?

They would be shown in the currency the player used to buy the first in-game currency, so a euro payer would see euros.

What counts as a child?

Anyone under 18. The rules for minors apply where a game is aimed at minors or the company is aware with reasonable certainty that they play it. The industry disputes how that is read.

How large are the fines?

Each country sets its own fines. The 6% of worldwide turnover often quoted belongs to a separate proposal that would let the Commission fine very large cross-border cases itself.

Money, Scandals, Phenomena

  1. The CS2 Skin Economy: Billions of Dollars, Million-Dollar Knives, and a $2 Billion Crash in 30 Hours
  2. The Biggest Thefts and Hacks in Gaming History: The $620 Million Axie Infinity Hack, Stolen CS2 Skins, and the GTA 6 Leak
  3. Star Citizen Has Raised a Billion Dollars — and Still Hasn't Come Out
  4. GTA Controversies: Lawsuits, Bans, and Hot Coffee
  5. Why Graphics Cards Are So Expensive in 2026: How AI Ate the Memory Supply
  6. Why have videogames become so expensive, and will they get even more expensive?
  7. Why Millions of People Click on Bananas, Cookies, and Cows: How Idle Games Have Hacked Our Brains
  8. What Are the Backrooms? Levels, Entities, Games, and Movie Explained
  9. Rusty Lake Series Phenomenon. Twin Peaks in the Form of a Point‑and‑Click
  10. Rideshare "Stimulator": What Kind of Game Is It and Why Did It Spark an AI Controversy?
  11. AI Is Already Taking Jobs in Game Development — Just Not Where We Expected
  12. DLSS 5 — Graphics Revolution or Marketing Gimmick? Let's Cut Through the Hype
  13. Why the Ocarina of Time Remake Announcement Divided Fans — Uncanny Valley, Politics, and Nostalgia
  14. Why AI Researchers Are Leaving OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google — and What They’re Warning About
  15. How GTA 5 Made More Money Than Any Movie Ever
  16. AI in Games: Why Players Boycott Studios Over AI Art and Voices
  17. How Much Money Has Genshin Impact Made and Why Gacha Is Cooling Off
  18. Sued for Being Too Addictive: How the Makers of Fortnite, Roblox and Minecraft Ended Up in Court
  19. The $250 Million AI Chat: How Krafton Asked ChatGPT to Escape Subnautica 2's Founders — and Lost
  20. What Was Found in the 12TB Steam Leak: Early Builds of GTA 3, Mafia 2, and Valve Games
  21. How Graphics Card Prices Spiraled: Mining, Scalpers, and Prices No One Could Believe
  22. The Live-Service Graveyard: How the Industry Burns Billions on Games That Die in Weeks
  23. Minecraft in Elden Ring and TNT in RDR2: The Wild AI Mashups That Broke the Internet — What's Real and What You Can Download
  24. Is Deadlock Out? Valve's Invite-Only Game Sets a New Player Count Record
  25. PS5 Jailbreak: What Relapse Offers and What You Risk
  26. EU Kids Act Explained: How It Could Change the Internet and Gaming
  27. Bloodborne PC Port and AI: Can Fans Port Games Without Permission?
  28. WARDOGS vs. Call of Duty: Can a $40 Shooter Hurt Modern Warfare 4?
  29. When and How Will AI Destroy Humanity? 5 Scenarios, Rated by AI
  30. Is Xbox Dying in 2026, or Just Being Told to Pay Its Own Way?
  31. How Valve Makes Billions from Steam — and Why It’s Facing Lawsuits
  32. Witcher 3 Remastered Player Count: Are Old Games Beating New Ones?
  33. Why EA Is Closing BioWare and What Comes Next for Mass Effect
  34. EU Gaming Law Plans and You: Kid Mode, In-Game Currency, Loot Boxes
  35. Teach Your Little Sister to Drive: You Talk to Her, the Developer Gets the Bill
  36. The Finnish Studio That Beat Apple on Value per Employee — Inside Finland's Strange Game Dev
  37. Steam Next Fest: Is AI Making Good Games Harder to Find?
  38. Phantom Blade Zero: 2026’s Biggest Single-Player Steam Launch, Explained
  39. Has Console Gaming Become More Expensive? PS5, Xbox, and What’s Next
  40. Switch 2 Jailbreak: How a Hacker Used AI and a $25 App
  41. Ocarina of Time Remake: Why Nintendo Is Learning from Its Past
  42. ARC Raiders Without PvP: Why Peaceful Raids Divided Players
  43. Roblox Bets on AI as Daily Users Fall 9% Year Over Year
  44. Huang Is Out: What Happens to NVIDIA and the AI Race Now?
  45. Worlds 2026 Opening Ceremony Backlash: Why LoL Fans Are Roasting Riot
  46. NOMERCY’s CS2 Match-Fixing Case: Lifetime Bans and the Price of Trust
    About the author
    Comments0